Warning: include_once(/home/kaylward/public_html/poll/poll_cookie.php): failed to open stream: Permission denied in /home/awards/public_html/2004/archives/2004_09.php on line 4

Warning: include_once(): Failed opening '/home/kaylward/public_html/poll/poll_cookie.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/lib/php:/usr/local/lib/php') in /home/awards/public_html/2004/archives/2004_09.php on line 4
2004 Weblog Awards: September 2004 Archives

September 28, 2004

Recapping the 2003 Weblog Awards

Have you forgotten the 2003 Weblog Awards allready?

Based on over 63,000 votes cast during the ten days polls were open (12/5/2003 -12/14/2003), here are the 22 winners of the 2003 Weblog Awards. Read on for the list of winners.

Best Overall Blog

Little Green Footballs

Best New Blog (Established in 2003)

Allah Is In The House

Best Group Blog

The Volokh Conspiracy

Best Foreign Blog

Merde In France
Merde In France

Best Humor Blog

Allah Is In The House

Best Looking Blog

Snazzy Kat
Snazzy Kat

Best Female Authored Blog (tie)

Meryl Yourish   Asymmetrical Information

Best Liberal Blog

Michael J. Totten

Best Conservative Blog

Hugh Hewitt

Best Media/Journalist Blog

Opinion Journal (Best Of The Web by James Taranto)
Opinion Journal
(Best Of The Web by James Taranto)

Best Ecosystem Higher Beings & Mortal Humans Blog

James Lileks
James Lileks

Best Ecosystem Playful Primates Blog

Citizen Smash
Citizen Smash

Best Ecosystem Large Mammals Blog

damnum absque injuria

Best Ecosystem Marauding Marsupials Blog

Patterico's Pontifications

Best Ecosystem Adorable Rodents Blog

Yale Diva

Best Ecosystem Flappy Birds Blog

Busy Mom Blog

Best Ecosystem Slithering Reptiles Blog

Buddha's Den

Best Ecosystem Crawly Amphibians Blog

Tasty Manatees

Best Ecosystem Flippery Fish Blog

Sweetness Follows

Best Ecosystem Slimy Molluscs (and below) Blog


Most Egregious Omission

Not A Fish

Ecosystem categories were based on The Truth Laid Bear Blogoshpere Ecosystem that ranks blogs based on the number of other blogs linking to them. The rating levels use a evolutionary metaphor. I think most people liked the idea of competing against sites from the same TTLB Ecosystem level, but I think for this year we are going to need some better "awards show" names for those categories. I'm open to suggestions...

Posted by Kevin Aylward at 09:50 PM | Comments (0) | TrackBack

Welcome To The 2004 Weblog Awards

Last year Wizbang hosted the extremely successful 2003 Weblog Awards. This year the 2004 version of the awards will be here on their own domain. You can bookmark The 2004 Weblog Awards now.

The 2004 Weblog Awards will continue the tradition begun here last year:

1) Open and public nominations
2) Categories that allow blogs of similar readership levels to compete
3) Real time vote totals
4) Quick turnaround of the results
5) Fun

Nominations will open Wednesday November 3, 2004. Many more details to follow.

Why were the 2003 Weblog Awards a success? I think they were successful because unlike nearly every other end of year award the 2003 Weblog Awards were as open and honest (except for a day of ballot stuffing - which was quickly fixed) as I could possibly make them. Nominations were public, and I did the best I could to get as many sites on the ballots in 20 different categories. Overall close to 400 blogs were in the running for awards. I even ran a Most Egregious Omission contest to prove that I wasn't trying to claim a mantle of infallibility.

Of course everything did not go perfectly... There was controversy about the inclusion of a Best Female Authored Blog (without a corresponding Male category); there were probably a few categories that should have been added; and there were a few categories that should have been removed. That said, most people took it for what it was - FUN, and did not get bent out of shape.

Posted by Kevin Aylward at 09:22 PM | Comments (6) | TrackBack